The uneasy alliance between Indian professionals and Donald Trump’s ‘America First’ movement is crumbling. At the heart of this growing rift is the battle over H-1B high-skilled work visas, a programme that has long been a gateway for Indian professionals to the American dream but is now a flashpoint in America’s immigration wars.
For years, Indian tech workers were celebrated as the “model minority,” seamlessly integrating into America’s tech-driven economy. However, the ideological core of Trump’s “Make America Great Again” (MAGA) movement has never been fully aligned with this vision. While Silicon Valley thrives on global talent, the nationalist base of Trumpism sees all forms of immigration skilled or otherwise as a threat to American jobs and culture.
The rise of Indian professionals in the U.S. was no accident. In 1965, the Immigration and Nationality Act eliminated racial quotas, paving the way for a wave of highly skilled Indian immigrants engineers, doctors, and scientists. These professionals embraced the American meritocratic ideal, becoming key players in Silicon Valley and the broader knowledge economy.
During Trump’s first term, many upper-caste Indian professionals found common ground with his nationalist rhetoric, particularly in their support for business-friendly policies and a hardline stance on China. Figures like Vivek Ramaswamy and Kash Patel became visible symbols of this convergence. However, this alliance was always precarious. The core of MAGA remains deeply rooted in white nationalism, which sees non-white immigrants—no matter how skilled—as outsiders.
The H-1B visa programme, which enables U.S. companies to hire skilled foreign workers, has become the focal point of this rupture. While corporate America champions H-1B workers as essential to maintaining U.S. tech dominance, MAGA’s populist wing views the programme as a conduit for job displacement and wage suppression.
Trump’s 2024 return to power only intensified these tensions. His administration’s renewed scrutiny of the H-1B system has sent shockwaves through the Indian tech community, which relies on these visas for career progression and stability. This growing hostility was underscored by the recent removal of Vivek Ramaswamy from Trump’s “Department of Government Efficiency,” a move widely celebrated by MAGA loyalists who increasingly see Indian professionals as part of the “globalist elite” they oppose.
The clash over H-1B visas is just one part of a broader ideological struggle. Indian professionals have long walked a tightrope between their economic success in the U.S. and the racial hierarchies they navigate. Many sought to distance themselves from broader immigration debates, assuming their high salaries and corporate contributions would shield them from nativist backlash. However, the MAGA base sees no such distinction. To them, Indian tech workers are no different from any other immigrant group challenging traditional American identity.
This friction is also mirrored in India, where economic liberalisation has empowered an elite class that blends capitalism with Hindu nationalism. Backed by political figures like Narendra Modi, this elite has cultivated strong ties with Silicon Valley while simultaneously pushing a nationalist economic agenda at home. The contradiction is stark: the same upper-caste Indians who benefit from U.S. immigration policies also support restrictive policies in India to maintain their dominance.
Trumpism has exposed the limits of this uneasy alignment. While Indian professionals champion free markets, Trump’s MAGA base prioritises economic protectionism. While Silicon Valley embraces global talent, nationalist conservatives demand American jobs for American workers. The cracks in this coalition were always visible, but now they have widened into an irreparable divide.
Online, the backlash is evident. Social media platforms like Reddit and 4Chan have become hotbeds of resentment against Indian tech workers, with accusations of “job theft” and “corporate favoritism” dominating discussions. Indian professionals, once seen as allies of the American right, now find themselves caught in a culture war where their very presence is a point of contention.
The failure of this alliance underscores a deeper truth: political alignments built on convenience rather than shared values rarely endure. As Trump’s second term unfolds, the Indian tech community in America faces an uncertain future. The question remains—will they continue to fight for inclusion in a movement that increasingly rejects them, or will they seek a new political identity beyond MAGA’s shrinking tent?
Stay ahead with the latest news on global innovation, leadership, entrepreneurship, business, and tech. Join us on WhatsApp or Telegram for real-time updates and expert insights.
Follow us on X (Twitter), Instagram, LinkedIn, Pinterest and Facebook for more insights and trends
