Canada is known globally for its commitment to human rights, progressive policies, and being a beacon of hope for individuals seeking better opportunities. Yet, behind this reputation lies an uncomfortable reality – migrant workers under the Temporary Foreign Worker Program (TFWP) are facing shocking levels of abuse, exploitation, and discrimination. A recent and deeply troubling report from Amnesty International brings to light the harsh conditions experienced by these workers, sparking urgent calls for reform and raising questions about the ethical practices within Canada’s labor market.
The Amnesty report, published on Thursday, sheds light on the deeply entrenched problems within Canada’s TFWP. This program, originally designed to fill labor gaps in sectors such as agriculture, food processing, construction, and hospitality, has instead become a breeding ground for exploitation. Amnesty’s findings reveal that the very structure of the TFWP makes migrant workers vulnerable to severe mistreatment, including forced labor, low wages, unsafe working environments, and a lack of access to basic rights and protections.
One of the most significant issues highlighted in the report is the use of closed work permits. These permits tie migrant workers to a single employer, leaving them with no ability to change jobs or seek better conditions without risking their legal status in the country. The power dynamics in such a situation are heavily skewed in favor of the employer, often resulting in abuse. Without the freedom to move between employers, workers are forced to endure whatever conditions are imposed upon them, knowing that speaking out or leaving could lead to deportation, a loss of income, or worse.
Amnesty International’s report is based on the interviews of 44 migrant workers, primarily from countries in the Global South, who bravely shared their experiences of exploitation and abuse. Many of these workers reported being subjected to long working hours, without proper compensation for overtime, and having their wages withheld by their employers. In some cases, workers described extreme levels of physical and psychological abuse, including being denied rest days, and working in unsafe conditions that resulted in injuries and health complications. The lack of adequate healthcare and safety measures left workers vulnerable to exploitation and often without any recourse for justice.
Among the most disturbing accounts shared in the report was that of Bénédicte, a woman from Cameroon who was subjected to both psychological and sexual abuse while working on a farm in Canada. On a closed work permit for two years, she faced severe mistreatment at the hands of her employer, who even went so far as to cancel her work permit when she attempted to leave the abusive environment. This left Bénédicte with an irregular migration status, making it even harder for her to find safety or legal standing within Canada. She described her experience with heartbreak and disbelief: “I did not expect to be a slave here.” This heartbreaking admission underscores the emotional and psychological toll such abuses have on migrant workers, many of whom arrive in Canada with hopes of securing a better future for themselves and their families.
Miguel, a Guatemalan worker, also shared his terrifying story of control and surveillance by his employer. His passport was confiscated, and cameras were placed in both his living quarters and workspaces, constantly monitoring his every move. This extreme surveillance, coupled with the fear of being deported or punished for even minor transgressions, left Miguel in a constant state of anxiety and fear. His experience highlights not just the physical abuses suffered by migrant workers, but also the deep psychological toll of living under constant surveillance with no escape.
The report also paints a grim picture of the living conditions many migrant workers are forced to endure. Amnesty discovered that numerous workers were compelled to live in overcrowded, unsanitary accommodations, lacking basic necessities such as clean drinking water and access to proper sanitation facilities. In some cases, the living spaces were so inadequate that workers were unable to rest or recover from their long working hours in any meaningful way. Beyond the poor living conditions, many workers also reported facing racial discrimination, with employers using their ethnicity as a basis for assigning them the most physically demanding, dangerous, and often degrading tasks.
Erika Guevara-Rosas, Senior Director for Research, Advocacy, Policy, and Campaigns at Amnesty International, expressed deep concern over the situation, calling it “deeply troubling” and calling into question Canada’s commitment to human rights. “The abuse experienced by migrant workers in Canada is deeply troubling, especially for a country that claims to be a leader when it comes to protecting human rights,” she stated. This sentiment reflects the collective disappointment of many who view Canada as a model of fairness and equality, only to see the exploitation of vulnerable migrant workers hidden beneath the surface.
Amnesty International has called for urgent reforms to Canada’s Temporary Foreign Worker Program, urging the government to align the program with Canada’s human rights obligations and ensure that workers are treated with dignity and respect. These reforms should include measures to ensure that migrant workers are given access to safe working conditions, fair wages, adequate housing, and legal protections that prevent exploitation and abuse. Ketty Nivyabandi, an Amnesty official in Canada, stressed that such reforms are essential to ensuring that the TFWP no longer contributes to the exploitation of workers but instead serves as a fair and just system that protects everyone’s rights.
In response to the Amnesty report, the Canadian government has acknowledged the issues raised but defended its record on worker protection. Nancy Caron, a spokesperson for the Canadian government, stated that the safety and dignity of temporary foreign workers are of paramount importance, and the government has already taken steps to address the concerns highlighted in the report. These steps include providing private health insurance, creating a tip line for reporting abuses, and working on policies that would allow migrant workers to hold open work permits, making it easier for them to switch employers if they face mistreatment.
However, many critics argue that these measures are insufficient and do not go far enough in addressing the systemic issues within the TFWP. For many migrant workers, the abuses they face are a daily reality, and without substantial changes, their situation is unlikely to improve.
For individuals considering migration to Canada or other countries, this report serves as a stark reminder of the risks and challenges involved. While there are undeniable opportunities for a better life abroad, it is essential to be aware of the rights and protections available, and to be prepared for the possible challenges that may arise in foreign labor markets. Migrant workers often leave their home countries seeking economic opportunities and a chance to build a better life, but as this report demonstrates, they may find themselves trapped in environments where their rights are disregarded, and their dignity is violated.
As the global workforce continues to expand, it is crucial to advocate for the rights of migrant workers and push for reforms that protect their safety, well-being, and human rights. By raising awareness of the issues facing migrant workers and calling for change, we can work together to create a more just and equitable system for all workers, no matter their background or origin.
Stay ahead with the latest news on global innovation, leadership, entrepreneurship, business, and tech. Join us on WhatsApp or Telegram for real-time updates. Have a report or article you want to share? Send it to report@theinnovationtimes.com. Follow us on X (Twitter), Instagram, LinkedIn, YouTube, Pinterest, and Facebook for more insights and trends.
